Venue Etiquette and Crowds
One of the most noticeable differences lies in venue etiquette. American wrestling events, particularly those of major promotions, are often characterized by crowds with tangible energy and excitement. Chants -sometimes supportive and other times unsupportive- are constant, and fans vocally express their approval or disapproval of the activity that is taking place in the ring. Signs or thundersticks are held high, and the overall environment is the feeling of an enthusiastic crowd having the social experience of attending a live event with friends and family, being in a venue with people who mutually love the entertainment value of professional wrestling.
In contrast, the atmosphere in Japanese venues is grounded in a deep, collective respect for the technical skill and athleticism of pro-wrestling, focusing on the drama of a match. The audiences are comfortable sitting in focused silence during the opening minutes of a match, quietly studying the technical wrestling and ring psychology. They express their passion by hanging wrestling banners in the venue, saying "woah" when they are surprised by a move, and uniting in rhythmic clapping to get behind a wrestler they like, being at their loudest when it appears that a match is going to end, as it seems that a wrestler they like is about to win or lose.
This difference stems from how both cultures view the nature of professional wrestling. While professional wrestling is generally considered to be a sport in Japan, in America it's presented as sports entertainment, which has developed an audience that is an active participant, reacting to the showmanship aspect of American wrestling. Meanwhile, fans in Japan view themselves as watching a high-level competition where every move makes the difference between victory and defeat.
Keep in mind that these are generalizations- for example, many American pro-wrestling fans appreciate a competitive match, and there are audiences in Japan who are lively and very talkative and expressive regarding their feelings, especially in Osaka. It's also worth noting that the internet and social media have caused an exchange of fan cultures, with fans from both countries sharing their perspectives and experiences, influencing each other. A perfect instance is that there are Western fans who have adopted the Japanese tradition of throwing paper streamers matching the colors of a Japanese talent's signature ring gear colors during their ring introduction at a US show, as a display of respect for them.
Personal Boundaries and Fan Interaction
Another contrast lies in the relationship between fans and wrestlers. Many American fans aggressively hunt for autographs at airports and hotels, to the extent that wrestlers have needed to go on social media and request personal space. Also, although those interactions are a result of admiration for the wrestler, there is also a purposely negative form of expression. There are people who are critical towards pro-wrestling while thinking that they know everything about it, and these people frequently express their views on social media, sometimes going as far as tagging specific wrestlers or the promotion that they work for.
Meanwhile in Japan, fans respect a wrestler's personal space and try their best to not be intrusive. I once saw a wrestler on a train after a show, and their ride was completely undisturbed. I watched Yoshiko making her way through fans in the crowded lobby of the Korakuen Hall before the start of an event, and fans allowed her to go about her business without trying to interact with her. I also witnessed fans pass by Ryuji Ito in a hallway of Korakuen Hall before a BJW event, and instead of the fans marking out over being in the presence of a definitive representative of Japanese-style hardcore wrestling, respectful nods were exchanged between the fans and Ito. Even when fans in Japan are expected to approach, there is hesitation- after an event at Shinkiba 1stRING, Emi Sakura was sitting at her merchandise table, ready to sell inventory. Because she is an established legend, fans were initially intimidated and unsure regarding approaching her.
Merchandise
The types of merchandise and fan activities also differ. While t-shirts and action figures are popular in both countries, Japan also puts an emphasis on programs, calendars, photobooks, and post-match photograph opportunities.
Transactional vs. Voluntary Support
Another difference is that while American wrestling fan culture has traditionally revolved around consumption of goods -where fans purchase tickets and merchandise from a promotion to satisfy their fandom- Japanese wrestling fan culture historically incorporates a collective, interactive element rooted in traditional support associations. In small promotions, this dynamic is represented by fan club members voluntarily working venue merchandise tables during shows, considering it a privilege.
While pro-wrestling fans in America and Japan are equally passionate, the cultural nuances of both countries have shaped distinct fan experiences and ways of expressing their fandom. Fans in America and Japan both contribute to the unique atmosphere of their respective country's wrestling culture, expressing their support and passion in their own distinctive ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment